Mechanics Monday: mobile phones and mixed reality

mechanic In the style of the Themed Thursday series inaugurated by Toronto Room Escapes which has spread elsewhere, the occasional Mechanics Monday series looks at individual elements of an exit game that are, more or less, taken as read as established practice, ask “What if…?” and ponder over the possible consequences of playing with the assumptions.

To a first approximation, it’s standard that exit games don’t let you take your cameras inside the rooms and don’t permit photos to be taken there. There are rare exceptions, especially if you’re a star of stage and screen performing in a touring show, taking in an exit game on a day off. Quite often you’ll read terms and conditions promising that bringing a mobile phone into an exit game is cause for disqualification without refund. Mechanics Monday asks: need this be the case?

Mobile phones are often powerful beasts these days, with theoretical deal-breakers being the abilities to (a) call someone and ask them for help, (b) devise solutions that might circumvent the intended solution processes, (c) take photos which might act as spoilers or (d) cause players to be less involved in the game and more involved in what is happening in their life outside the game. While (c) is certainly a reasonable concern, this site would argue that it might not be as big a stumbling-block as you might expect.

There’s nothing stopping people from writing about the contents of exit games as it is; people tend to be well-behaved enough to understand, and live by, the reasons for the societal prohibition. Would they follow by the same prohibition if they could take camera shots inside the room? If you’ve got some particularly cool and unusual (and selfie-worthy) items or decorations inside the room, perhaps it would raise the bar on how exciting the designated photo area outside the room would have to be in order to make it the photo location of choice, but otherwise it would seem likely that people would play fair.

Issues (a) and (b) might be considered issues of “cheating”. However, if players can be assumed to have access to modern mobile phone technology, then the puzzles inside the room can be designed to take advantage of that technology. Mixed reality applications are becoming increasingly popular, where digital images are overlaid upon physical items. The first of these have been quite crude, but it’s definitely possible that future generations of technology may be much more sophisticated. Permitting access to phones would also enable research-based puzzles, which could also help engage people in the narrative you have established.

It’s true that not everyone has access to a smartphone, and there are several varieties of operating systems (and even different versions of the same operating system). Perhaps it might require presenting a standard simple mobile phone (or some similar device using at least some of the same technologies – a generic technological magic wand) to be used as a prop in the game whether a team have access or not. Yes, these are valuable, but it’s likely that the team will be dealing with expensive equipment whether it includes a phone or not. This would also neatly bypass issues of different user experiences.

This would be an unusual angle to take, but it’s not necessarily one worth dismissing out of hand. Perhaps a site with many different games could include one which permitted the technology, as well as the majority that do not. If this is a step too far now, is there ever a point in the future where this will change – will disallowing access seem like a deliberate retrograde step to a former era?

7 thoughts on “Mechanics Monday: mobile phones and mixed reality”

  1. I’d be surprised if someone somewhere isn’t using AR in a room. Even just including a phone with instructions to scan the room with an app on it, revealing ‘hidden’ messages on items. I mean, it’s just a high-tech way of doing UV and blacklight but a bit different.
    I’ve actually only had one site actually ask me to leave my phone outside. Most say ‘no photos’ which is fair enough, the rest I take as read that I’m not going to take it out of my pocket and start Googling during the game, but it goes in with me nevertheless. Though I can’t think of many circumstances where using it would actually have been beneficial. Maybe for the calculator function and some anagrams but that’s about it.

    I think the other part of it is the analogue/digital divide. There are a bunch of people going properly apoplectic about the fact that the new XCOM board game requires an app. Because they hate having technology in their board games and think that board games are going to turn into video games. That’s not the case there, the app merely enhances the game, acts as a component, as I imagine it would in an exit game. I don’t see “get a high score on Bejeweled on this iPhone to unlock your next clue” happening any time soon.

    Weirdly enough, we’re back around again to the Cyberdrome Crystal Maze, which had games that purely digital on touch screens, games that were purely physical (with the screen just giving instructions and managing succeed/fail) and ones that were hybrids (someone has to go do something physical while someone else does something on screen.

    1. Possibly another question is whether the techniques are being used to their full capacity. If they’re simply being used as high-tech invisible ink, that’s not actually all that much fun, and there may be different and more fun forms of invisible ink to use (for instance, I really enjoyed rain.works, though I don’t know quite how applicable it could be to an exit game).

      The crossover between board and digital games goes back longer than you might think; one of my favourite games of all time is Brian Clough’s Football Fortunes, approaching 30 years old, which did a remarkably good job at playing to board games’ discussing, deal-making strengths and computers’ calculation and accountancy strengths. I did recently read someone refer to the digital aspect as an “app”, and the thought of loading an app from a tape feels quite wrong.

      The Cyberdrome Crystal Maze is another of my favourite games of all time – in fact, that and BCFF are certainly both top five, probably top three along with the live-action role-playing campaign I played at university.

  2. I have played an escape room (which shall remain nameless, and was while I was traveling away from home) where one chain of puzzles led you to a mobile phone without its battery, and another chain led you to its battery, and a third led you to a phone number.

    I totally expected to have to put all three together — assemble the phone, put it together, and look up the phone number in its contacts database. I’ve seen that in other escape rooms.

    But no — you’re just supposed to call that number. This escape room doesn’t ban phones! So you can just call it on your own phone, and then you don’t have to solve the other two puzzle chains at all. When I inquired with the proprietor during the debrief, he said, oh, those are just there in case nobody brings a cell phone. He did admit that the likelihood of nobody in a 10-person team having a cell phone with them is around 0.00000%.

    So I like your ideas, but I wouldn’t recommend that particular technique!

    1. One UK game I’ve played already had an iPhone (or probably iPod Touch) as part of its solution. Frankly, they’re just hand held computers unless you connect them to the internet/mobile phone, and there are at least two other games I’ve played in the UK where I’ve used computers. For a sufficiently high tech person, it would be possible to set an Android phone that looked like a phone, but actually just connected to the WiFi in the room and played back prerecorded messages (or even just connected you to your game host). Alternatively you could set up your WiFi to allow very limited internet access – either to a small set of websites, or even just to your own personal server with caricatures of modern websites (maybe you could “Woogle” a search term or log in to “Lacebook” to get info about the characters?

      Obviously you have to have a setting where a phone is appropriate – the game where I saw it was generally old fashioned decor, so the iPhone was a dissonant feature. Futuristic (or just modern) games would be fine.

      PS Loving the blog!

  3. Very belated comment, but: there’s one escape room in Singapore where you eventually discover a smartphone which you have to use to scan QR codes (with a twist which I shan’t divulge here). Each QR code scanned results in a little message popping up on the screen, until you get the correct one.

    There was also another escape room (now closed) where there was a phone in the room and you had to check its contact list (or perhaps sent messages, I forget) for a clue. That model was just a regular Nokia from the early 2000s, though.

Leave a Reply