Where are the gaps in the UK market?

Map of UK and Ireland with regions highlighted

It’s possible that some of the first exit game room proprietors might have started business in the closest big city to where they happened to already live. However, if you had a choice as to where to set up business, where are the most obvious gaps in the market? Alternatively, where might people expect to see exit rooms coming soon?

The Brookings Institution analysed 300 of the largest metropolitan economies in late 2012 and identified 15 of them as being in the UK. At time of writing, here are the 15 largest metropolitan economies in the UK, alongside the number of exit rooms featured in each one. If there’s a large metropolitan economy without an exit room, there’s arguably a gap in the market there.

1. London: two sites operating (HintHunt, clueQuest)
2. Birmingham: one site operating (Keyhunter)
3. Manchester: one site under construction (Puzzlescape)
4. Leeds-Bradford: no sites operating or under construction known
5. Liverpool: no sites operating or under construction known
6. Glasgow: no sites operating or under construction known
7. Nottingham-Derby: no sites operating or under construction known
8. Portsmouth-Southampton: no sites operating or under construction known
9. Bristol: one site operating (Cryptopia)
10. Newcastle: no sites operating or under construction known
11. Sheffield: no sites operating or under construction known
12. Cardiff-Newport: no sites operating or under construction known
13. Edinburgh: no sites operating or under construction known
14. Leicester: one site operating (Cipher)
15. Brighton: one site under construction (Live Escape Game)

For reference, while the list of metropolitan areas organised by economy size does not exactly match the list of metropolitan areas organised by population, the other existent sites operating are ESCAP3D in Belfast (13th by population) and Ex(c)iting Game in Oxford (33rd by population). For comparison, the Dublin metro area (where XIT is in operation) would come just below number three in the above list.

So this would tend to point to Manchester, West Yorkshire, Merseyside, Glasgow and the East Midlands as being the biggest gaps in the market at the moment. Less scientifically, I have a suspicion that Blackpool still retains its cachet as the most popular seaside resort and might yet support a site. I’m not saying where I live, but it’s not one of the metropolitan areas listed above!

5 thoughts on “Where are the gaps in the UK market?”

  1. Interesting analysis! Hope it prods people into action.

    Kind of confirms my calculation last year that Ipswich is too small to sustain one (yet), as we don’t have significant numbers of tourists here like Oxford (which is a similar size) does.

    1. I’m sure it’s just coincidence that I posted that on March 10th and Make A Break opened in Manchester, my top suspect, on March 16th.

      Yes, this is the sort of thing I would do if I knew that a site were to be just about to open, but sadly nobody tells me these things in advance. Yet…

    2. Hi, Mo! I don’t know if this will reach you. If it doesn’t reach you directly then I may well just e-mail you directly with this.

      What a great time to be… you! You in particular, you with what you’ve done for the last thirty years. It feels like it has all been leading up to – on a commercial level – your absolute time to shine. (Creatively, I know you’ve been shining like… not just one star, or even one constellation, but a whole zodiac for decades.)

      I know you’ll have known about Jubensha for longer than many people have been talking about it – I bet it’s been discussed at every Knutepunkt you’ve been at for several years now – and it’s not as if gamer circles even distant from the Knutepunkt cutting edge haven’t been talking about it for a while. However, People Make Games’ latest video on the topic contains a pretty explicit call to action on the genre, and they’re the sort of people who can get people talking and get things going when they call to action.

      I’m not going to suggest that your Freeform Games games are Jubensha, because I know you’ll have known about it for so long and you’ll deliberately have chosen not to go down that route, you’ll deliberately have chosen not to appropriate a cultural term from another culture. I am going to suggest that between what you’ve been doing with Freeform Games and all your other LARP endeavours over the years, you absolutely could go down the Jubensha route if you wanted to, and all your experience would mean that you could do it incredibly well. Hell, there’s a Dragon’s Den pitch right there if you wanted one. (“Heard about this Jubensha thing which is sustaining 20,000 businesses in China? We’ve basically been doing it for a quarter of a century already…”)

      Why am I responding to this comment in particular? It’s because it’s evidence that in 2014 you considered running an escape room and rejected it. There are escape rooms in Ipswich now, and you could have got in any time you wanted. Was it the right thing to do not to get into running an escape room? That’s for you to decide. I’d bet you’d have done it bloody well if you’d wanted to. Would you have got more from doing so than you have done in practice from your other creative and commercial endeavours? …eh, on balance, I’m going to guess at “probably not”.

      But 2014’s “should I run an escape room?” feels a lot like 2024’s “should I run a jubensha?” to me. My suspicion is that the culture will be more receptive to jubensha now than it would have been to escape rooms then, in part because of the existence of escape rooms and dozens of sorts of other games, and you’ve seen that there have grown to be hundreds of the buggers all over the place. I also have a suspicion that the world has changed enough (and there have been enough successful immersive theatre models already) that you could make a high-end chamber LARP work on an escape-room-like model, but at a price point that could genuinely sustain a business, and – again – I’d bet on you being able to do this superbly with your decades of experience and understanding. I also think that the existence of Freeform Games gives you an ideal base to offer something deliberately and unashamedly high-end, because you’ve also got the high-quality low-end already in place if that’s what people want.

      Now is the time! Go and SMASH IT!

      1. ah Chris thank you for thinking of me, and for your too-kind words! and goodness mm was that really ten years ago? wow.

        And of course you are absolutely right, in all your deductions here — and we are currently looking into some potential commercial possibilities that this new wider awareness of jubensha may open up.

        I’m not taking an active role in that myself, because I’ve been quite ill for the last few years now, and so running the operational side of our current business is about all I can manage at the moment. But my business partner is putting some work into this development area at the moment.

        It might not come to anything — our existing model is a very comfortable one, and doesn’t require a lot of labour or capital, and still has plenty of growth potential that we’re working to exploit — so we would need a very convincing business plan to divert a load of energy into something that by its nature is more risky. But it might happen! We shall see.

        (And by all means please do drop me an email too, it would be lovely to hear from you and catch up a bit.)

Leave a Reply