Coming back for more

Picture of an illustrated story bookA follow-up question to that of how popular exit games are is the issue of how to get players to come back for more, for repeat business may well play a significant part in keeping a site thriving over time. It may be easier to convince someone to play an exit game if they know what one is from having played one already.

Some sites offer more than one different room, which seems likely to be a lucrative move. Perhaps someone who enjoys one room at a site can be convinced that another room at the same site is likely to be of a similarly high quality; there will always be people for whom the novelty of playing an exit game once is sufficient, but there will also always be enthusiasts who are keen to get the joy of an exit game as many times as possible. Many sites say that they change their rooms from time to time, though this represents a considerable investment.

It has also been suggested that it’s difficult to tell much of a story within an hour. It’s tempting to wonder – asking in the context of a theorist, rather than someone with experience in the business – whether it might be possible to run a campaign of connected exit room games, at a single site, telling an extended story within the same universe. If someone enjoys a game, they might well be tempted to go back for the next episode, and the episode after that, and so on. Theoretically, it might even possible to permit the players to affect their ongoing story, with choices they make when playing an early episode having an effect on their experience in later episodes.

One model has people, when they book to play, specifying if they have played any episodes in the series previously, then the room is dressed in a slightly different way according to which part of the story happens next. This requires great communication between the players and the room dresser, for if players miscommunicate their needs then they may end up playing the wrong game (and possibly feeling aggrieved about it, even if it’s their own fault). Another downside is that it would probably be impractical to have different physical attributes of the room for each episode, unless a much bigger physical room is built and not all of it is used in each episode. This seems likely to be needlessly expensive.

Perhaps a workable solution would be to have several story episodes in a connected universe that can be played in any order, or story developments that can be caught up through narrative as well as through gameplay. (It’s easy to imagine a team of four coming for the first episode, then only three of them coming for the second episode, then a slightly different four for the third episode, and so on.) To be fair, this seems to be the approach taken by at least one site already.

It’s a considerable additional level of complication to consider, but one that potentially could multiply a site’s revenue several times without the expense of having to find new players over and over again…

How popular are exit games?

Counter graphicAn open question, possibly of interest, asks just how popular the exit games of the UK and Ireland are. This site has attempted to estimate the number of people who have ever played any of the exit games that we cover, and will attempt to update its estimates over time.

The alpha-version methodology this site proposes to use, and criticism is most welcome, is to attempt to estimate the number of teams that have played over time at each exit game site in the UK and Ireland, then from there to estimate the number of players. Estimating the number of teams relies on a number of sources of data. Some sites have quoted numbers of teams or players having taken part, which may or may not be taken at face value. At least one site appears to have past booking information still available, which may not be deliberate but certainly is extremely helpful (though, again, may not represent the full picture, depending on how phone bookings interlace with online ones).

As for the rest, the estimate (stress, estimate!) can be based on the number of rooms at each site, the apparent occupancy rate of each room according to booking data, but also data such as social media data regarding posts of game results, alongside more nebulous data (treated rather more lightly) such as numbers of Facebook likes and TripAdvisor reviews. This is not a rigorous approach but may be adequate for an extremely rough estimate.

After estimating the number of teams, we can attempt to estimate a number of players. It seems reasonable to take pictures posted to social media as a reasonably representative sample of actual team sizes at that site, noting that different sites (and even different games at a site) have different rules about the number of players per team. From there, it is worth applying a correcting factor to take account of the proportion of players who will have played more than one exit game, whether two (or more!) rooms at the same site, or at two (or more!) different sites.

Possibly the lessons to be drawn from this are that the two London sites appear to be doing excellent business, particularly with their recent expansions to 4 and 3 rooms (and both have further expansions soon planned!), and that there is not yet the evidence to support any of the sites outside London doing nearly so well – though only one site outside London has yet reached its first birthday, and surely the business models have not relied on the sites being instant hits. It can probably also be interpreted that the existing sites have only scratched the surface of potential players, and there are perhaps between a hundred and a thousand times as many potential players as yet-achieved players.

This site estimates the number of people to have played an exit game in the UK and Ireland by the end of April 2014 to be around 33,000. This site is not at all confident in this estimate, to the point where it could well be one third of that, or could be three times as high. That’s not too inconvenient – this site can at least be confident in saying “probably in the tens of thousands”!

(This site would be keen to discuss and improve its methodology, especially if any additional data that can be provided in confidence for authentication, but chooses to keep its estimates for individual sites and individual time periods to itself.)

Approaches to difficulty in exit games

GameCamp logoYesterday, at GameCamp in London, there was a talk on the exit game phenomenon given by Adrian Hon. It’s not clear what GameCamp etiquette is, whether what gets said at GameCamp stays at GameCamp, whether things can be reported under the Chatham House Rule, or whether there can be wider reports, but it would be great to hear more from the event. Failing that, Adrian discussed the genre towards the end of episode 41 of “The Cultures” podcast.

Some exit games take the approach that they will be very generous with the distribution of hints to their players, even making it clear that this is the policy right at the outset, in the discussion before players enter the room. As this was the approach taken by the first exit room site to open in the UK, this may well be the dominant approach nationally.

By contrast, there are other sites which offer some games where few or no clues are offered. The pitfall there is either that you set the difficulty level relatively high and have no or very few people crack the room, or you set the difficulty level relatively low and risk having people finish the game in less than half the permitted time, which can be something of a flat ending. There are plenty of other solutions, especially if players are prepared to enjoy the possibility of partial credit for solving some, but not all, of the game, but these appear to be less frequent.

Incidentally, the “deliberately very few winners” approach is the one taken by many of the games offered by SCRAP, considered the originators of the genre, among other operators. Befitting the Japanese origins of the “Nintendo hard” stereotype, as an example, their “What is the Real Escape Game?” page talks of a 2% success rate, and their Flickr photostream has a couple of photos of ongoing scoreboards suggesting victory rates not much higher than that. (Anecdotally, more recent games suggest an easing of standards to around 10%.) This site is not yet aware of any UK exit games that take quite such an extreme approach.

The issue of difficulty of exit games is an open one; there appears not to be a consensus on a single correct approach. As different players want to face different challenges, this variety of approaches may well be a good thing for the world. The difficulty is to match potential players up to the right game for them. This web site will do whatever it can to help in this regard.

The Keyhunter site in Birmingham takes a particularly interesting approach in this regard; it advertises its three games as having different levels of difficulty, and advertises its teams successes on social media not only in terms of the time they took but also by how many clues were needed. If you want the added challenge of completing an exit room and having “with 0 hints used” decorating your performance, perhaps Keyhunter might be the right site for you. There may well be other games that offer the same option and this site will make it clear when it’s available.

Mazebase, the company behind two UK exit rooms

Mazebase game logopuzzlair3
Yesterday’s post, about discovering the existence of Puzzlair, came about as a result of finding out that Mazebase existed. Mazebase are the company who designed HintHunt in London and Puzzlair in Bristol, and also have a room in Debrecen, Hungary and another in Athens, Greece. However, over the years, they have developed seven different rooms in total. Perhaps some of the others will come to the UK or Ireland some day.

If you’ve ever considered starting your own exit room, Mazebase have some packages available. They’re reasonably priced, considering how popular the rooms are, though I imagine the rental costs that cannot be included in a package are likely to be the major part of the expense of running the business. As a player, you might at first think that the price of playing an exit game is high; however, if you consider the rent, business rates and labour expenditures, to name but three expenses, I get the impression that there is no room at all for the operators to cut their prices and that the profit margins may well be very thin as it is, even despite how popular the games are.

A famous advert for a breakfast company says “We don’t make cereal for anybody else”; it is unclear whether any of the other exit room operators would be prepared to offer their services as well as Mazebase. If you’re interested in starting your own exit room, I guess it would be worth talking to the operators of other existing sites already and seeing whether they, too, might also be prepared to provide their services.

I hope to get to interview the people behind Mazebase before long, and any other operators who might be willing to talk about the services they can offer as well as the games that they run.

Where in London could the next exit game be?

London skylineLondon plays such a vast role in the UK economy that it comes as no surprise that it can sustain two exit rooms already. The two there already are both very successful, jostling with – of all the things – the Brick Lane Music Hall in the top 3 list of TripAdvisor’s reviewers’ London attractions.

It possibly should also be no surprise that it could well be the location of a third and quite possibly many more exit room sites; compare with Budapest having 44 exit room games and the rest of Hungary 22. Escape Hunt is open in Bangkok and lists London as a location in which it will have opened by June; I like the ambition and look forward to following other locations’ progress along the way.

I did enjoy reading plans to start an underground farm deep below the surface of London, in one of apparently eight deep-level bomb shelters built in the 1940s. That strikes me as potentially an extremely atmospheric location to situate an exit game!

The Wired article suggests that “There have been occasional requests from ambitious club promoters to host parties in the tunnels, but the lack of appropriate fire escapes makes it an unfeasible venue” – and, I fear, that might rule them out for ever hosting exit games. Nevertheless, perhaps this might not be an insurmountable problem after all, and the returns could be spectacular!

Where are the gaps in the UK market?

Map of UK and Ireland with regions highlighted

It’s possible that some of the first exit game room proprietors might have started business in the closest big city to where they happened to already live. However, if you had a choice as to where to set up business, where are the most obvious gaps in the market? Alternatively, where might people expect to see exit rooms coming soon?

The Brookings Institution analysed 300 of the largest metropolitan economies in late 2012 and identified 15 of them as being in the UK. At time of writing, here are the 15 largest metropolitan economies in the UK, alongside the number of exit rooms featured in each one. If there’s a large metropolitan economy without an exit room, there’s arguably a gap in the market there.

1. London: two sites operating (HintHunt, clueQuest)
2. Birmingham: one site operating (Keyhunter)
3. Manchester: one site under construction (Puzzlescape)
4. Leeds-Bradford: no sites operating or under construction known
5. Liverpool: no sites operating or under construction known
6. Glasgow: no sites operating or under construction known
7. Nottingham-Derby: no sites operating or under construction known
8. Portsmouth-Southampton: no sites operating or under construction known
9. Bristol: one site operating (Cryptopia)
10. Newcastle: no sites operating or under construction known
11. Sheffield: no sites operating or under construction known
12. Cardiff-Newport: no sites operating or under construction known
13. Edinburgh: no sites operating or under construction known
14. Leicester: one site operating (Cipher)
15. Brighton: one site under construction (Live Escape Game)

For reference, while the list of metropolitan areas organised by economy size does not exactly match the list of metropolitan areas organised by population, the other existent sites operating are ESCAP3D in Belfast (13th by population) and Ex(c)iting Game in Oxford (33rd by population). For comparison, the Dublin metro area (where XIT is in operation) would come just below number three in the above list.

So this would tend to point to Manchester, West Yorkshire, Merseyside, Glasgow and the East Midlands as being the biggest gaps in the market at the moment. Less scientifically, I have a suspicion that Blackpool still retains its cachet as the most popular seaside resort and might yet support a site. I’m not saying where I live, but it’s not one of the metropolitan areas listed above!