The League Table: end of May 2014

Picture of a generic trophyThis is the second installment of an occasional feature to act as a status report on the exit games in the UK. On its own it means little, but repeated sufficiently many times it could be the basis of a survey of growth over time.

Exit Game sites known to have opened in the UK/Ireland: 12/1
Exit Game sites known to be open in the UK/Ireland: 11/1
Exit Game sites known to have closed temporarily in the UK/Ireland: 1/0
Exit Game sites known to have closed permanently in the UK/Ireland: 0/0
Exit Game sites known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0
Exit Game sites less confidently known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0

Site name Number of exit rooms Number of different games Number of TripAdvisor reviews Number of 5/5 TripAdvisor reviews Local TripAdvisor ranking
Breakout Manchester 1 1 4 4 62
clueQuest 3 2 426 411 1
Cipher 1 1 – – –
Cryptopia 1 1 24 21 9
Escape 2 1 7 7 81
ESCAP3D 1 1 73 62 3
Ex(c)iting Game 2 2 17 12 22
HintHunt 5 2 805 748 3
Keyhunter 3 3 38 25 6
Make A Break 1 1 22 15 12
Tick Tock Unlock 1 1 9 9 19
Puzzlair 2 2 36 36 2
XIT 4 4 3 2 101

This needs to be taken with a heavy pinch of salt. This site supports all the exit games that exist and will not make claims that any particular one is superior to any other particular one. Please note that the TripAdvisor rankings represent a wide variety of locations and cannot be directly compared against each other. In fact, it’s probably pushing it even to compare the tripAdvisor rankings of two exit game sites in the same city. One site has received four ratings over the course of the month, all 5/5, and has promptly dropped six places within its city. Seems strange; what more might it do?

Updating our estimate as to how many people have played an exit game in the UK or Ireland, we will revise our prior estimate for the number of people by the end of April 2014 up to 34,000 and the estimate for the number of people by the end of May 2014 up to 39,000. (As usual, this is not a confident estimate, but should be correct to within a factor of three.) The expansion of HintHunt from four rooms to five at the start of June is likely to have a reasonably large effect in future months.

How popular are exit games?

Counter graphicAn open question, possibly of interest, asks just how popular the exit games of the UK and Ireland are. This site has attempted to estimate the number of people who have ever played any of the exit games that we cover, and will attempt to update its estimates over time.

The alpha-version methodology this site proposes to use, and criticism is most welcome, is to attempt to estimate the number of teams that have played over time at each exit game site in the UK and Ireland, then from there to estimate the number of players. Estimating the number of teams relies on a number of sources of data. Some sites have quoted numbers of teams or players having taken part, which may or may not be taken at face value. At least one site appears to have past booking information still available, which may not be deliberate but certainly is extremely helpful (though, again, may not represent the full picture, depending on how phone bookings interlace with online ones).

As for the rest, the estimate (stress, estimate!) can be based on the number of rooms at each site, the apparent occupancy rate of each room according to booking data, but also data such as social media data regarding posts of game results, alongside more nebulous data (treated rather more lightly) such as numbers of Facebook likes and TripAdvisor reviews. This is not a rigorous approach but may be adequate for an extremely rough estimate.

After estimating the number of teams, we can attempt to estimate a number of players. It seems reasonable to take pictures posted to social media as a reasonably representative sample of actual team sizes at that site, noting that different sites (and even different games at a site) have different rules about the number of players per team. From there, it is worth applying a correcting factor to take account of the proportion of players who will have played more than one exit game, whether two (or more!) rooms at the same site, or at two (or more!) different sites.

Possibly the lessons to be drawn from this are that the two London sites appear to be doing excellent business, particularly with their recent expansions to 4 and 3 rooms (and both have further expansions soon planned!), and that there is not yet the evidence to support any of the sites outside London doing nearly so well – though only one site outside London has yet reached its first birthday, and surely the business models have not relied on the sites being instant hits. It can probably also be interpreted that the existing sites have only scratched the surface of potential players, and there are perhaps between a hundred and a thousand times as many potential players as yet-achieved players.

This site estimates the number of people to have played an exit game in the UK and Ireland by the end of April 2014 to be around 33,000. This site is not at all confident in this estimate, to the point where it could well be one third of that, or could be three times as high. That’s not too inconvenient – this site can at least be confident in saying “probably in the tens of thousands”!

(This site would be keen to discuss and improve its methodology, especially if any additional data that can be provided in confidence for authentication, but chooses to keep its estimates for individual sites and individual time periods to itself.)