Sometimes issues crop up in the real world with unexpected relevance in the world of puzzle competitions as well. The week before last, the chairman of the Football Association, Greg Dyke, released an England Commission report, regarding supporting the number of English players involved in the game at a high level, hoping to boost the chances of the English national team down the line. The aspect of this which has most caught people’s attention is the proposal to permit clubs to enter second (or “B”) teams into the existing structure. The proposals have largely proven unpopular. However, the world of puzzle competitions has faced similar issues in the past.
B teams at the World Puzzle Championship
Some years, the World Puzzle Championships have permitted nations to enter “B” (and, very occasionally, “C”) teams as well. Officially, the individual ranking order only includes the (up to) four designated “A” team members per country, and the team ranking order only includes “A” teams with four members; if a country enters fewer than four members, they will get individual rankings, but the country will not get a team ranking.
Unofficial ranking orders are also produced, ranking “A” team members alongside “B” team members and sometimes (see, e.g., Beijing 2013) even guests as well. Only “A” team members are eligible to take part in play-off competitions held as grand finals. Sometimes it happens that a non-“A”-team member performs well enough that they would have made the play-offs and are excluded from participation, but there is no outcry against this practice. The theoretical issue comes if a non-“A”-team member outperforms all the “A”-team members and yet still cannot enter the playoffs; people seem reasonably content that this is likely to be only a theoretical issue, sufficiently unlikely to crop up (and risk asking questions about the validity of that year’s championship title) in practice.
Consensus of opinion seems to be in favour of “B” teams; again looking at Beijing 2013, a majority of the most successful nations sent whole “B” teams, and it may well be that many of the “United Nations” teams are made up of incomplete “B” teams. At one point, the World Puzzle Federation board never reached a conclusion on the issue and left it to individual championship organisers whether or not to accept “B” teams; the principle of “B” team and guest participants paying a slight surcharge to subsidise “A” team participation, particularly from “A” teams whose members would otherwise not be able to afford to participate, seems to have proven popular. (Personally, I fully support it.)
B teams in the Croco-League
The issue of “B” teams also appears in the Croco-League online team puzzle competition, as previously discussed. Here, teams can choose to name themselves whatever they like, and some teams choose to name themselves as being the second team of another, established, team in the league. There is no formal tie between the two teams; it’s not possible for a “B” team to send players to the “A” team or vice versa, other than through the usual routes which (largely) only permit players to leave established teams between seasons.
It’s probably fair to compare this to the World Puzzle Championship tradition. It’s also probably fair to say that the Croco-League doesn’t just draw on the tradition of association football leagues, it draws on the tradition of the German league system in particular, which has long featured clubs’ reserve teams at a reasonably high level.
Several of the Croco-Puzzle teams draw their membership from whole countries and name their team accordingly, which is fun. As so many of the site’s users come from Germany, naturally enough, many of the teams draw their membership from specific parts of Germany and name their team accordingly, which is also fun. When there are more solvers from a non-German country than can fit in a single team, some communities have tended to organise themselves into “A” and “B” teams, whereas the UK tradition so far has been to have a Northern UK team and a Southern UK team. (Even then, the distinguishing line is whether someone feels Northern or not, for any other boundary would effectively be as vague and arbitrary – people move, people are not distributed evenly around the UK, and so on.)
I feel strongly that, as much as I support “B” teams in the World Puzzle Championships, I oppose “B” teams in the Croco-League. It’s fun to feel like you’re competing against the best that a country, or a region, has to offer; it’s much more meaningful to feel like you’re competing against the best that a small locality has to offer than to feel like you’re competing against the second (or third, etc.) best that a larger area has to offer.
It’s not for me to tell other communities how to organise their teams, but I definitely have a strong preference for a geographical split. After all, in the World Puzzle Championship, you (barring velvet revolutions and independence referenda) can’t choose which country you represent; in the Croco-League, it’s easy to start a new, more tightly-focused team.
Perhaps my preference for there being many teams with tight geographic bases is a direct reflection of my familiarity with the English football league tradition rather than the German one. I am strongly against the proposal for “B” teams in the English football leagues, so perhaps it is not surprising that I have counterpart feelings about the Croco-League.