Puzzle TV update

"The Genius" garnet and logoIt’s a joy to have a good excuse to use the above logo again; the fourth series of Korean sensation The Genius is now under way. At time of writing, the first two episodes have been broadcast, translated and covertly reposted with English-language subtitles. The subtitle of this series is GRAND FINAL, and it’s an all-star series; the thirteen contestants have all played one or two of the first three series – and, furthermore, they include the top two finishers from each of the first three series. (Sadly, some of the most entertaining and biggest mouths of the first two series aren’t back.)

This site previously discussed the show; in summary, imagine Big Brother with really smart contestants playing proper clever, puzzly games. You can jump in at the start of the fourth series which stands alone, but you may also get more from being familiar with the personalities if you’ve watched the first three series (highly recommended; the games broadly get more interesting and better-played over time, but the first series has the single most brilliantly-played game to date and the second series has the single most brilliant piece of gameplay, which is not quite the same thing). Links to shows plus translations are at the usual place.

While the UK isn’t cool enough to have The Genius, it does have dear old Only Connect, brilliant in its own right and its own fashion – though this site maintains that the show has, metaphorically, put on a jazzy bow tie ever since it moved to BBC 2, just for a giggle. The new series starts on Monday 13th July. Get in early if you can, because you stand much more chance – though still not much of a chance, unless you’re good! – at being able to play along with the episodes at the start of the series. BBC FOUR starts its brand new show, Hive Minds, on Tuesday 14th July, hiding its tricky quiz answers in word search puzzles with hexagonal grids. The clips suggest that there may well be some play-along-at-home value to it.

Later in the month, with most direct relevance to exit games, the Science Channel in the US is launching Race To Escape, as previously discussed. Some more videos have been posted, one featuring the rules to the game. (Two teams compete to escape identical rooms; the first team to escape within 60 minutes wins a cash prize. Escape within 20 minutes and win $25,000; take longer than that and the money starts to tick away at $500 per minute. Optional clues reduce the potential prize by $5,000 each.) One video suggests that they’re going to use some techniques for the show’s clues which this site would consider a little exotic because real-life exit games cannot have a TV budget; this is good to see, and probably essential because many of the show’s viewers are likely to have played games and seen the relatively simple stuff first-hand. Fingers crossed!

Coming soon to London: Adventure Race

Adventure Race logoLisa Long, so prominent within early DASH, early Puzzled Pint, Girls and Boys Come Out to Play and all manner of other exciting London puzzle events, points to an exciting-looking treasure hunt taking place in London on Saturday 18th July, AdventureRace.London.

“AdventureRace.London is a treasure hunt in Central London in aid of charity. ((…)) Led by an adventurer from the Inspired50, discover secret London whilst completing fun, challenging tasks that test your intelligence, endurance and team working skills. ((…)) Teams are made up of five members. Each team will receive a printed clueboard which contains clues to challenges to complete during the race, some more cryptic than others. It is up to each team to unravel the clues on the clueboard and pinpoint the location of each challenge. All locations can be found in the Bank, St Paul’s, London Bridge, Borough and Bermondsey areas. Challenges can be completed in any order, with the exception of the first, although you may choose to strategise and plan your route thereafter.” Tickets are £30 plus a booking fee – or, for £40, you can be on a team with a named captain, whose life history may make them worth meeting.

There are a couple of other distinctive features. As well as challenging participants to raise funds over and above the ticket price, participants are challenged to make a positive difference and brighten another person’s day during the course of the race itself. If all goes to plan with both fundraising and deed-doing, the event has a goal of using its 100 participants to raise £10,000 and a hundred good deeds. There’s also a planned attempt on the Guinness World Record for the world’s largest word search, set to be about a 25% expansion on the 250×204, 5500+-clue monster presented at a college in Utah two and a half years ago that possibly still holds the record.

There have been events a little bit like this in the past, and there’s a continuum between a puzzle hunt and… well, orienteering. (Don’t get this site wrong; this site thinks orienteering is cool, just a different sort of cool, with plenty of other web sites that talk about it already.) At one end of the spectrum, speed of travel is all and the time taken on the challenges is almost incidental; at the other end, speed of travel may be disregarded, or all but disregarded, and the time spent on the challenges is key. Where does this event fit in? It’s not quite clear, but the event’s background sounds promising. The fact that it’s using technology from Fire Hazard also pushes it in this general direction.

Possibly vaguely comparable games might include the (past) Great Urban Race and The Go Game, both of which have had events in the past in the UK, though not in recent years. Possibly the most successful member of the genre was Intelligent Sport; this was a property of sports rights company IMG Media, famous for Trans World Sport and more, so it shouldn’t come as a surprise that they managed to get a show with some of the races on Channel 4 in the middle of the night, a couple of hours after the poker. (There are some episodes on YouTube.) The results site details the problems that were thrown up as parts of the race, which still exists under the name the UK Challenge.

If you’re thinking of playing, you might particularly enjoy this episode of Snoutcast which interviews two standouts of the Great Urban Race, also members of the puzzle hunt family, which might put you in mind for what to expect from a footrace-heavy treasure hunt.

Coming soon to Norwich: Cryptic Escape

Cryptic Escape logoEast Anglia’s first stationary exit game arrives imminently; Cryptic Escape, of Norwich, is now open for bookings from tomorrow, Friday 10th July. This site has been in touch with the man behind the new game for some time and really looking forward to its launch. The location is tremendous: go to Norwich Cathedral’s main entrance, turn around and you’ll see a white building with an external wooden frame, thought to be almost half a millennium old. (Jailbreak! at Oxford Castle sputters at the newcomer.) Augustine Steward House, where a Tudor merchant who was the city’s mayor three times once lived, hosts Cryptic Escape, along with a number of other businesses.

The site is launching with one game, though two more are promised to be added soon. The first game is a very popular Mazebase classic, The Laboratory of Dr. Lev Pasted; it’s also available at Puzzlair in Bristol, but that’s a good couple of hundred miles away. This is the secret hideout and laboratory of the mysterious Romanian geneticist and biologist Dr. Lev Pasted. In his late years he focused his experiments on some kind of blood elixir. The formula is gone, so has the doctor. Some say, that the secret blood serum is still inside the lab hidden somewhere. It’s a 60-minute game for teams of two to five.

In the near future, the site will shortly add The Treasure of Green Beard, in which The players have 60 minutes to find the hidden treasures of the famous pirate Captain Green Beard. The treasure is well hidden in his old hideaway, where he lived while he wasn’t sailing and robbing around the Caribbean seas. A little further down the line, you may be able to get to know The Steampunk Explorer, the tale of The famous explorer Thelonius Winter, who travelled from Victorian time, into the future to retrieve a mystical and powerful relic, then returned back to the past. More news when they become available.

The site charges £40 for a team of two and £10 for each extra player, so teams of five are charged just £70. The site’s promotional video is rather fun, too!

Early July exit game news

Newspaper graphicExit game news from three parts of the UK today.

1) In London, Time Run have extended their, er, run from 2nd August until at least 30th September – excluding Mondays, as ever. That said, from 3rd August onwards, the off-peak (weekdays before 5pm) price rises from £24 plus VAT per player to £29 plus VAT per player, and the peak price rises from £29 plus VAT per player to £35 plus VAT per player.

Unrelatedly, Room Escape Adventures‘ Trapped in a Room with a Zombie has moved within town to Whitechapel; ScareTOUR report that the game’s operation has been taken over by Apocalypse Events, who already run plenty of other zombie-themed experiences in the capital. Charmingly, on Valentine’s Day, they had Zombie couples makovers in the same venue as the old TiaRwaZ site…

2) Further north, Logiclock of Nottingham have announced that their second room will be Made in STEIN: Science Adventure. The STEIN company, standing for Science, Technology, Entertainment, Innovations and Novelty, previously had an employee called Professor E. “You’ll enter Professor E.’s room. Professor E. had to go very quickly and without attracting attention. He had to leave so fast he couldn’t find somebody who could continue his work. There are lots of candidates but he needs the best of the best. The Professor asked Mrs. Taylor, his assistant for help. In order to prove your skills you have one thing to do: escape from Professor E.’s room“.

3) Further north still, Breakout Games Inverness of the Highlands announced that they hosted their first proposal! This isn’t an industry first or even a UK industry first – Breakout Manchester have hosted at least one and this site would bet that it isn’t an industry second either – but this is as happy as news gets, and hiding the engagement ring inside the last puzzle is the classiest possible way to do it.

A persistent urban myth is that some stores’ managers have the discretion to celebrate a customer’s waters breaking in their shop with free vouchers and the like. When will we see the first exit game host an unexpected birth on the premises… let alone a labour lasting less than an hour?

News round-up: convention, DASH 7 video and sudoku championships

News round-upLots going on at the moment. Normally this would be three separate posts, but there’s so much else to write about!

1) This site recently mentioned the Escape Games Convention in Stuttgart, Germany on 4th September. Katharina Wulf of co-hosts ExitVentures (who are apparently putting together a printed German-language magazine) wrote on a forum as follows:

“We (as the oragnizing team) are trying to make it valuable to come for English speaking people as well. Here some information in English: One highlight will be the talk of Attila Gyurkovics. He is the first operator of live escape games in Europe with ParaPark (Budapest) and the first one who developed live escape games on the basis of flow theory. Attila Gyurkovics will talk about his experience and his future visions. Prof. Nicholson (Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada) will give scientific insights into the field and an overview over the North American market via video message.

((…)) In addition there will be some workshops focusing on following topics: “Live escape games next level” (about innovative new room concepts) and “Live escape games association” (about the creation of common structures for the industry in Germany). ((…)) The video message from Prof. Nicholson and the speech from Attila Gyurkovics will be in English. Beside that we will offer the workshops in English, too. Furthermore we will be able to provide you with information in English for the other agenda items. In the session the participants will elaborate relevant topics in small groups. This can be realized in German or English.”

It’s looking ever more tempting, especially for us non-German-speakers!

2) The UK Puzzle Association are running their annual UK Sudoku Championship online this weekend. Start after midday on Thursday, up until the end of Monday, and you have a two-hour window of your choice to score points by solving the 17 sudoku and sudoku variant puzzles. The top two finishers will earn places on the UK team for the World Sudoku Championship. It’s always a great contest for sudoku fans and there are no charges for taking part.

3) Lastly, back at DASH 7, Yasmin Curren took extensive video through the day. She has taken weeks of hard work, for which we’re all surely very grateful, to apply her magic; the results are a spectacular three-minute summary of the fun to be had, though perhaps the puzzles – being less telegenic – have to take second place. Be sure to look out for the Quidditch, Wronski Feint and all:



Now open in Bristol: Fathom Escape

Fathom Escape logoGoing the whole nine yards – or, at least, two yards – is Fathom Escape of Bristol, which opened at the start of the month. The site offers a single game with a one-hour time limit, designed to be played by a team of up to ten. Smaller groups are welcome and will be merged together as far as possible – though do note that Escape Game Addicts recently had a fantastic story about a solo player taking on a game intended for up to ten, and winning with time to spare.

The theme and storyline are not stated explicitly, though the title, graphics and the image of a diving helmet might suggest a nautical flavour, as do references to sinking of swimming. There’s also demonstrated use of rather an old-fashioned lamp and ancient-looking books; all this points to a game coming out of the Ocean Zone. Games are charged at a regular price of £17.99 per player, but the first hundred tickets are being sold at half price: just £8.99 a head. Games are available between 10:30am and 10:30pm, every day except Mondays.

Happy sailing!

Around the world: Getting together

Hands around the worldIt’s definitely possible to draw parallels between the development of the exit game hobbies in different countries around the world. People start exit games, there become enough of them to inspire people to want to talk about them, eventually players and operators think about meeting up. Doubtless there will be other parallels still that develop in different places independently over time as well.

1) “National character” is lazy shorthand for prejudice, but it’s a compliment – and an amusing one – that the first country sufficiently organised to run an Escape Games convention is Germany. The line-up looks exciting, though more likely to be of interest to site owners than anybody else – but when you get enough people interested in the genre in the same place at the same time, magic will happen pretty organically. There’s a reduced price for bloggers; if there’s anyone out there who wants to represent Exit Games UK who isn’t working the night shift on September 4th and either speaks German or just doesn’t mind requiring people to translate for them all day, please get in touch.

2) Talking of bloggers, that’s not quite how it works in Canada. Some of the exit game bloggers of the Greater Toronto area, and their talented theatrical friends, will be putting on three sittings of a one-night 100-player stadium-style exit game. In your Night at the Speakeasy (a Prohibition-era illegal drinking den), explore the rooms, solve puzzles, interact with the actors, don’t get whacked by da wise guys and find the exit on September 19th in the Canadian Caper. This is horribly impressive, they’re going to have such fun, they have such accomplished track records that this site firmly hopes that the event is as huge a hit as it deserves to be.

3) Talking of bloggers and stadium-style games, EscapeGame.Paris announced that The Real Escape Game came, and are coming, to France; three of the four sessions of the SCRAP-derived mass-participation event have happened already, the fourth is set to follow soon. Given that Real Escape Game have brought their games to France and also to Spain, this site is very positive about the chance of it coming to the UK at some point as well.

4) So what does the UK have? Well, the UK will have The Crystal Maze, and this site is organising an industry meetup there. 14 tickets have gone, 18 tickets remain. If you’ve vaguely expressed interest in the past – even if just as a comment to a post – then please convert it into actual interest now; you should have received details by e-mail about how to send money and guarantee your place, but please get in touch if you haven’t.

5) However, all of these rely not just on being in certain countries, but also on being in certain cities within those countries. If you’re not in the right city, you can get together remotely this weekend by taking part in the seventh (“Swiss”) round of the World Puzzle Federation’s Grand Prix puzzle competition; 90 minutes to score points by solving 23 puzzles of seven different types. The download the Instruction Booklet page will let you find if this contest is the right one for you.

Codex Bash

Codex Bash in playYesterday saw a spectacular evening of play hosted by the Wellcome Collection, practically opposite Euston station in London. The games were excellent, the company even better still. One interesting game, Goggle, presented by Ivan Gonzalez, might be considered a cross between tag rugby and capoiera from the perspective of someone who has played neither. (Retrieve tags from your three competitors’ belts, but you must all glide gracefully about the play area to the regular, slow beat of a drum. Special difficulty: you’re all wearing the titular goggles which restrict your vision.) The sessions about game poems – games designed to be thought about rather than played – were also delightfully provocative.

However, likely to be the most relevant game to readers was Codex Bash by Alistair Aitcheson. It’s as close as this site has seen to an arcade game version of an exit game, and this site hopes that the world at large gets to play it. For instance, an exit game facility with a bar or a cafe might choose to install the game and feature it as an attraction to be enjoyed by patrons of the bar, either as a warm-up before they went in to play their exit game, or as a fun cool-down afterwards. (Or just as a standalone.) It wouldn’t be far from something that could be incorporated into an exit game, though it would take a certain sort of game to appreciate it, or it could be an attraction by itself at a site.

Codex Bash sees teams of arbitrary size decode messages by following instructions and hitting sequences of oversized coloured buttons against the clock – big chunky Bishi Bashi Special buttons, practically game show buzzers. So far, so Simon without the memory, or Pop’n Music without the rhythm. However, the buttons are some distance apart from each other, so the game must either be played by either a team working in co-operation, or a single player running from button to button.

Codex Bash at its simplestThe real twist is that only the first level has direct instructions as to which button to push. Later levels do not present the instructions directly, but require the team to decode an instruction to work out which button to, from an on-screen excerpt of the titular codex.

These start simple; here’s a symbol, and here’s a chart as to which symbol means which button. They get more complicated and more interesting; here’s a little maze to follow, or here’s a grid to read, or here are some cartoon faces on coloured backgrounds, here are some facial features, find them on one of the faces and push the appropriate button. Later levels still might need you to follow multi-part sequences of symbolic relationships, or press two buttons at once (tricky for solo players) or – most interestingly – use decoding information that isn’t given on-screen but is given on physical objects elsewhere in the room that you have to find.

Some parts of the codex are found elsewhereThe number of ways to dress the encryption up, or otherwise play with the rules and conventions of the game itself, are practically endless – and there’s replay value because different games will use different techniques. There could even be different difficulty levels using the same physical equipment; easy mode might be forgiving of mistakes while emphasising the time limit – particularly as this could well be played by bright kids, too young for most exit games – whereas hard mode might get very quickly to the tough stuff and change the focus somewhat from “be fast” to “be accurate”.

The structure of the game as it was played last night was that teams had eight levels to complete, with an overarching time limit of four minutes, but a delightful Out Run-style time extension of 45 seconds after each level. Each level used a different encryption technique and required three sequences (of perhaps five or six button bashes) to be decoded through that technique. Running out of time would end the game; making five mistakes within a single level would do so as well. For what it’s worth, my team lost our game, but we got to the last level!

The presentation, graphics and sound are tremendously appropriate and fun; 80% cartoon-y, 20% game show-y. Maintaining it would require a few hardware skills, maybe electronics skills unless the big button and networking components are available off-the-shelf, but very light by exit game standards. The game as displayed required minimal manual intervention to start the game, but it seems likely that it wouldn’t take much development to turn it into a coin-op. The trailer will give you the feel of a slightly earlier version.

The Codex Bash hardware: just add a big, big screenIt’s a game that tickled some of the same parts of the brain as an exit game might; the frantic activity against time, the co-operation, the simple decoding, the variety, the use of the environment. Of course, there are so many other important areas that it didn’t even try to reach – narrative, plot progression, properly thoughtful, multi-part puzzles – and at the end of the day it’s a game which only empowers the player with one verb, push a button, so it’s inherently limited. The description “arcade game version of an exit game” fits it well, and that’s a delightful additional genre of game to exist in the world.

Author Alistair Aitcheson (incidentally, apparently unaware of the exit game genre, despite inadvertently having come close to reinventing a version of it) has a number of other works as well, playing with traditional boundaries between physical games and video games, often using the physicality of humans operating tablets as the medium. He’s brilliant! Sign him up! Codex Bash is definitely the piece of his work with most obvious relevance to exit games to date, though.

The semester report for early 2015

A book displaying "Semester Readings"The single months’ worth of TripAdvisor that are tracked in the League Table feature are only really meaningful as snapshots in time. However, with sufficiently many of them, it is possible to draw slightly more meaningful trends – or, at least, to reflect on how far the industry has come. The Timeline shows that the number of known open exit games in the UK more than doubled over the first half of 2013, more than doubled again over the second half of 2013, doubled over the first half of 2014, more than doubled once more over the second half of 2014 and more than doubled once more still over the first half of 2015. (Those numbers: 1 to 3 to 7 to 14 to 30 to 64.) Past performance is not an indicator of future results, as you may have previously been told, which is just as well or the metaphorical king’s chessboard will become swamped with rice. Already the latest square is looking alarmingly full.

It’s worth occasionally looking at trends in popular reviews of exit games in the UK and Ireland, taken from TripAdvisor statistics. This site is using a little more reserve than once it did with regards to what it says, bearing TripAdvisor’s terms of use in mind; the aim is not to laud or criticise particular sites in this regard, more to look at the bigger picture. Besides, if you run a site and care about your performance in this regard, it’s probably not difficult to work out which site is which from context. As usual, there’s more than a hint of truth in xkcd’s snark about online star ratings; in this world, anything other than full marks (and, especially if you’re on eBay, several pluses and stars) is a “diss that don’t miss”. It’s not necessarily a healthy state of affairs for anyone who cares about subtlety, graduation and shades of light and dark – but, with this in mind, are five-star ratings quite as common as they used to be?

Here’s some raw data, aggregated over the universe of TripAdvisor reviews for exit games in the UK and Ireland that this site was able to find.

Time period Number of reviews Number of 5* reviews Proportion of 5% reviews
To end of June 2014 1665 1532 92%
Second half of 2014 2240 1998 89%
First half of 2015 4248 3900 92%

From these figures, it would be tempting to suggest that the market has increased in quality over the last six months. Indeed, using a z-test, it is statistically significant at a highly meaningful (0.01) level that the proportion of 5* reviews has increased from H2 2014 to H1 2015, but there is no statistical significance in the changes between reviews from “H1 2014 and before” and reviews from H1 2015. These are not quite comparable statistics to the ones that this site presented six months ago; these reflect reviews of all exit games open at that time, rather than comparing like with like directly. They also make the considerable (and untestable) assumption that the standard required for a 5* review is the same as it ever was. An explanation may be as simple as people enjoy playing (mostly indoor) exit games more when they do so in the relatively cold first half of the year than when they do so in the relatively warm second half of the year.

It may be closer to comparing like with like to only consider the 22 sites that have been open since before July 2014, where we have meaningful numbers of reviews (10+, and even that’s a stretch) for H2 2014 and for H1 2015.

Site location Second half of 2014 First half of 2015
  Reviews 5% reviews Prop’n 5% Reviews 5% reviews Prop’n 5%
South 49 41

84% 79 70 89%
N.I. 28 16

57% 24 18 75%
N.I. 28 24

86% 15 13 87%
Midlands 16 5

31% 11 1 9%
South 53 50

94% 64 60 94%
Scotland 226 204

90% 203 167 82%
Scotland 36 35

97% 103 98 95%
Scotland 21 21

100% 119 113 95%
Scotland 68 66

97% 122 109 89%
North 221 210

95% 200 194 97%
North 66 63

95% 156 150 96%
London 292 270

92% 189 178 94%
London 381 348

91% 220 207 94%
London 80 68

85% 37 30 81%
London 92 70

76% 71 54 76%
London 20 19

95% 23 22 96%
London 61 48

79% 104 73 70%
North 14 14

100% 31 30 97%
North 150 133

89% 172 155 90%
Midlands 32 21

66% 27 20 74%
North 232 217

93% 210 203 97%
North 16 16

100% 95 90 95%

The first column is classified as Scotland, Northern Ireland, London, and provincial England is split roughly into North, Midlands and South. There is further ordering in the table which this site chooses not to make explicit but is not hard to deduce. (If you run a site and can’t work out which site you are, you could always ask.)

So, only among these 22 popular and well-established sites:

Time period Number of reviews Number of 5* reviews Proportion of 5% reviews
Second half of 2014 2182 1959 90%
First half of 2015 2275 2055 90%

Practically unchanged – though, beyond the decimal point, a rise from “just under 90%” to “just over 90%”. If one particular site had been getting 100 reviews with 90% 5/5s previous to one half-year and then another 100 reviews with only 75% 5/5s in a half-year then there might be cause for alarm, but the sample sizes here are generally so small that there are only one or two cases in which the observed lowering of the percentage for a particular site is at all meaningfully significant. Run your own tests!

There is one very important assumption that this analysis makes, that the reviews that people leave are a genuinely representative sample of participants. Different sites seem to perform more or less effectively at converting participants into reviewers and it is not clear why. Looking at the geographic locations of reviewers, it’s also sometimes possible that more than one member of the same team might choose to leave a review for some games, though there’s not necessarily anything wrong with that; it’s conceivable that different members of one group might leave – say – both a ***** review and a *** review, rather than the group leaving a single **** review. It’s not unknown, in the wider world at large, for there to be such things as fake reviews; this site isn’t aware of it having happened in the exit games it covers, but it’s not as if it has performed meaningful investigative journalism in this regard.

In conclusion: exit games were awesome up until the second half of 2014, and have been just as awesome in the first half of 2015 as well.

DASH7: the numbers game

Now that's a numbers game

Now that‘s a numbers game

Three points of number work from the recent DASH hunt. Where did London’s conspirators spend your money? Did any cities do better or worse than others. And if your team scored 311 on the Novice track, what’s that worth in Expert points? Continue reading DASH7: the numbers game