Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes

Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes logoFrom time to time, Exit Games UK likes to use some of its hard-earned near-topic credit to write about video games – but not just any video games, specifically video games that might be found in the lobby of an exit game to give you something that’s the right sort of fun to do before or after your game. See the review of Codex Bash previously. (For something even more kinetic and hilarious – though rather less practical for an exit game lobby – see its follow-up, Go! Button Power Team!, where the buttons to be pressed are on humans in zentai suits. Special difficulty: these humans have their own silly instructions which may make finding and pressing the buttons a remarkable challenge.)

The recent meeting of the Haberdashery Collective was tremendous, featuring all manner of unabashedly silly party-style games in an excellent, inclusive, friendly atmosphere. The game discussed today, that this site experienced for the first time at the very end of the session, is Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes. It’s a PC game, distributed via Steam, in which one player has access to a digital version of a suitcase-style bomb, and the rest of the team have access to a printed bomb defusing manual. The bomb has a number of modules on it, each of which hosts its own miniature puzzle. Through accurate description of these modules, and also other information about the composition of the bomb, the remainder of the team can look through the instructions for how to solve that puzzle and convey the solution technique for each module back to them. The instructions are fairly convoluted, but only just convoluted enough to be fun. It’s a game of observation and communication. Oh, and make sufficiently many mistakes or take too long and the bomb will, well… do what bombs do.

The bomb is procedurally generated to be different every time; there are fourteen different types of module, and some are harder than others. You can dial the level of difficulty up or down; a relatively easy bomb will have few modules and ones which are relatively simple to solve, a more complicated bomb will have modules up the go-go and pose real-time multitasking challenges to test your time management while you’re doing everything else. Maybe once you’ve cracked each sort of module twenty or thirty times, the appeal might start to fade, but the game walks the tightrope between high intensity and low stakes with style. This would make it a really suitable game for an exit game lobby; it’s almost instantaneous to pick up and play and very easy to come into and drop out of.

You can get a sense of whether this a game that you’d enjoy playing yourself by looking at the instruction manual and looking at videos online of people playing the game. Arguably that’s a little spoiler-y and it’s better to go in completely cold – think of the joy of being immersed to brand new games to figure out within seconds on The Crystal Maze – but there’s something of a difference between seeing a game played and getting to play it yourself. There’s a 10% discount available on the (reasonably small) price of the game for about another 24 hours or so right now, with a note that no further discounts will be planned for the next six months, so now might be a great time to act if you’re interested.

As a cultural point, this site thoroughly approves of the renaissance of resilience-building games. “Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.“, as Samuel Beckett would have it. To an extent that’s every video game, but there’s a difference between resilience at problem-solving and resilience at reflex-testing, noting that almost all games have elements of both. On top of that, apparently Keep Talking… is compatible with certain VR headset development kits, which must be an absolute blast, no pun intended. If, on the other hand, you know about Keep Talking… already, the physical exit game with most similarities to the digital game is very probably Agent November‘s Major X Plow-Shun game, which gives you a physical box of tricks to play with.

Lastly, and unrelatedly: congratulations to the UK team in the World Sudoku Championship, whose eighth place is a national best for five years, and particularly to David McNeill for defending his world championship in the over-50s division. Take this great form into the World Puzzle Championships and puzzle ’em dead!

Coming soon to London: street game “Shadow over Shoreditch”

Shadow over Shoreditch graphicThis site has touched upon the work of the Fire Hazard street games company in the past. Their stock in trade is energetic outdoor gameplay, often evoking movies’ chase sequences. City Dash is their breakout hit, popular wherever it has been tried. However, the basic principle of a chase game is easy to replicate; customised software to keep people precisely in touch with the state of play during the race is a lot harder and there are other variations on an intuitive and simple theme that can be tried to keep people coming back for more.

October’s game will be Shadow over Shoreditch. “The ladies and gentlemen of the Lumos Society race to seal the portal as sinister shapes slither from the shadows. Can your team of heroes crack the clues, escape the shambling horrors, and still have time for tea?” This iteration of the general principle aims to be a lot more theatrical than its predecessors.

The briefing will be in character, players are invited to dress for atmosphere as well as for practicality (“Encouraged (but not mandatory). Think ‘vintage adventurer’, perhaps with a dash of Steampunk ((…)) perhaps a collared shirt and a waistcoat?“), teams will be chased by squiddling Tentacled Horrors From Beyond and the afterparty will take place at the very cool Ziferblat, featuring custom-designed cocktails for the event. If the inhabitants of Shoreditch can go all-in for the likes of Secret Cinema, there’s no reason why other games couldn’t affect some similar sense of occasion. (A tip of the hat to the likes of Time Run and Trapped in a Room with a Zombie, possibly the state of the art for theming in exit games.)

As for the game itself: 50 players meet at our HQ, and our crew help you get into teams, pick up your map, and get the game running on your phone. Then we’ll brief you and send you all off into Shoreditch at once. Now you’ve got an hour to score as many points as you can. Find checkpoints in any order by looking at your phone to see the latest cryptic clues, get there, and look for the hidden code. Type that into your phone to update the scoreboard. But at the same time, watch out for our patrolling monsters. They don’t need to catch you – they only need to see you, so you’d better hope that someone on your team is keeping a lookout!

That hints at the other major step forward for this game compared to its forebears. No longer are you being chased by agents who wish to take their own photo of you in order to penalise you, but by monsters who need no such obvious tools and will cause collateral damage through their mere proximity. How can that be made to happen in real life? Arthur C. Clarke’s Third Law reads “Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic“; let’s leave it at that!

Shadow Over Shoreditch will take place at 8pm on each of the last four Thursdays and last four Saturdays of October. Tickets start at £8 per player for the preview event on Thursday 8th October, early bird tickets are £15 per player, with the Hallowe’en special wrap party being £25 per head. If you love craftsmanship at the cutting edge, don’t let this one fall into darkness past you.

Codex Bash

Codex Bash in playYesterday saw a spectacular evening of play hosted by the Wellcome Collection, practically opposite Euston station in London. The games were excellent, the company even better still. One interesting game, Goggle, presented by Ivan Gonzalez, might be considered a cross between tag rugby and capoiera from the perspective of someone who has played neither. (Retrieve tags from your three competitors’ belts, but you must all glide gracefully about the play area to the regular, slow beat of a drum. Special difficulty: you’re all wearing the titular goggles which restrict your vision.) The sessions about game poems – games designed to be thought about rather than played – were also delightfully provocative.

However, likely to be the most relevant game to readers was Codex Bash by Alistair Aitcheson. It’s as close as this site has seen to an arcade game version of an exit game, and this site hopes that the world at large gets to play it. For instance, an exit game facility with a bar or a cafe might choose to install the game and feature it as an attraction to be enjoyed by patrons of the bar, either as a warm-up before they went in to play their exit game, or as a fun cool-down afterwards. (Or just as a standalone.) It wouldn’t be far from something that could be incorporated into an exit game, though it would take a certain sort of game to appreciate it, or it could be an attraction by itself at a site.

Codex Bash sees teams of arbitrary size decode messages by following instructions and hitting sequences of oversized coloured buttons against the clock – big chunky Bishi Bashi Special buttons, practically game show buzzers. So far, so Simon without the memory, or Pop’n Music without the rhythm. However, the buttons are some distance apart from each other, so the game must either be played by either a team working in co-operation, or a single player running from button to button.

Codex Bash at its simplestThe real twist is that only the first level has direct instructions as to which button to push. Later levels do not present the instructions directly, but require the team to decode an instruction to work out which button to, from an on-screen excerpt of the titular codex.

These start simple; here’s a symbol, and here’s a chart as to which symbol means which button. They get more complicated and more interesting; here’s a little maze to follow, or here’s a grid to read, or here are some cartoon faces on coloured backgrounds, here are some facial features, find them on one of the faces and push the appropriate button. Later levels still might need you to follow multi-part sequences of symbolic relationships, or press two buttons at once (tricky for solo players) or – most interestingly – use decoding information that isn’t given on-screen but is given on physical objects elsewhere in the room that you have to find.

Some parts of the codex are found elsewhereThe number of ways to dress the encryption up, or otherwise play with the rules and conventions of the game itself, are practically endless – and there’s replay value because different games will use different techniques. There could even be different difficulty levels using the same physical equipment; easy mode might be forgiving of mistakes while emphasising the time limit – particularly as this could well be played by bright kids, too young for most exit games – whereas hard mode might get very quickly to the tough stuff and change the focus somewhat from “be fast” to “be accurate”.

The structure of the game as it was played last night was that teams had eight levels to complete, with an overarching time limit of four minutes, but a delightful Out Run-style time extension of 45 seconds after each level. Each level used a different encryption technique and required three sequences (of perhaps five or six button bashes) to be decoded through that technique. Running out of time would end the game; making five mistakes within a single level would do so as well. For what it’s worth, my team lost our game, but we got to the last level!

The presentation, graphics and sound are tremendously appropriate and fun; 80% cartoon-y, 20% game show-y. Maintaining it would require a few hardware skills, maybe electronics skills unless the big button and networking components are available off-the-shelf, but very light by exit game standards. The game as displayed required minimal manual intervention to start the game, but it seems likely that it wouldn’t take much development to turn it into a coin-op. The trailer will give you the feel of a slightly earlier version.

The Codex Bash hardware: just add a big, big screenIt’s a game that tickled some of the same parts of the brain as an exit game might; the frantic activity against time, the co-operation, the simple decoding, the variety, the use of the environment. Of course, there are so many other important areas that it didn’t even try to reach – narrative, plot progression, properly thoughtful, multi-part puzzles – and at the end of the day it’s a game which only empowers the player with one verb, push a button, so it’s inherently limited. The description “arcade game version of an exit game” fits it well, and that’s a delightful additional genre of game to exist in the world.

Author Alistair Aitcheson (incidentally, apparently unaware of the exit game genre, despite inadvertently having come close to reinventing a version of it) has a number of other works as well, playing with traditional boundaries between physical games and video games, often using the physicality of humans operating tablets as the medium. He’s brilliant! Sign him up! Codex Bash is definitely the piece of his work with most obvious relevance to exit games to date, though.

Old puzzle, new twist

rsz_paradox-33849_640One of the most familiar logic paradoxes runs along the lines of:

Poaching on the hunting preserves of a powerful prince was punishable by death, but the prince further decreed that anyone caught poaching was to be given the privilege of deciding whether he should be hanged or beheaded. The culprit was permitted to make a statement – if it were false, he was to be hanged; if it were true, he was to be beheaded. One logical rogue availed himself of this dubious prerogative – to be hanged if he didn’t and to be beheaded if he did – by stating: “I shall be hanged.” Here was a dilemma not anticipated. For, as the poacher put it, “If you now hang me, you break the laws made by the prince, for my statement is true, and I ought to be beheaded, but if you behead me, you are also breaking the laws, for then what I said was false and I should therefore be hanged.”

— pages 187-8, Edward Kasner and James Newman, Mathematics and the Imagination, 1940

Suppose, instead, the protocol ran like so:

1) If the statement were false, he was to be hanged;
2) If the statement were true, he was to be beheaded;
3) If the truth or faleshood of the statement could not be determined, he was to be killed in some other equally grisly fashion.

The question is whether this is a complete partition of the entire space, or whether there are still gaps that remain to be exploited. This site has a few examples of the infinity of statements that could reasonably be expected to lead to the man dying of natural causes. (If you’ve ever done any formal study of logic – and this site has not yet had that pleasure – this is probably a topic that gets covered as late as the second half of the first lecture; despite the subject line, there’s surely nothing that new here.)

The follow-up question is: if you can spot the loophole in the protocol above, or some other loophole that this site has not yet thought of, how do you go about amending the protocol so that the loophole no longer exists, or at least some more convoluted loophole has to be used instead?

Expect spoilers in the comments!

Saturday night treat: “Schlag den Brig”

"Schlag den Brig" logoThis is more likely near-topic than on-topic, but there are several very fine, very puzzly people involved, and the first attempt in January was a spectacular success.

One of Germany’s most spectacular TV shows is Schlag den Raab. The title refers to regular house contestant Stefan Raab, a TV host, musician and comedian, might be thought of as a German version of Jonathan Ross crossed with Vernon Kay… in their dreams. He’s as prolific and important as a US late-night talk show host who’s been attracting A-listers for 20 years. In Schlag den Raab, Raab takes on a contestant in a series of 15 games. The games can be mental, can be physical, will often be outdoors, can often be spectacular. It’s a test of “Who’s best at everything?”.

The first game is for 1 point, the second game is for 2 points and so on; there are 120 points possible, so the first to 61 wins overall. (If it finishes 60-60, there’s a sixteenth game.) The most exciting thing is that the show starts at 8:15pm and runs, live, as long as it has to in order to find a winner. Maybe it finishes as early as midnight; maybe it runs past 2 a.m. The show is that important and popular that people will stay up as late as they have to, to see who wins. There are pretty A-list musical guests, as well.

Part of the attraction is that Raab is very competitive and extremely good at what he does. The show is so big-budget that they run it as a special, six times a year. There have been 46 episodes to date; Raab has won 32 and lost 14. He’s beaten an Olympic gold medallist, a Boat Race participant, and some pretty high-powered competition.

That’s Schlag den Raab, this is Schlag den Brig; the Raab role is played by Nick Gates, known as Brig Bother in his guise as host of the superlative Bother’s Bar web site. The Bar discusses UK and international game shows, with a heavy emphasis on the puzzlier end of the spectrum. It was very probably the foremost English-language discussion site for the amazing, puzzle-laden Korean show The Genius (series one discussion and series two discussion) and the Dutch Wie is de Mol?.

Schlag den Brig is an online event broadcast live as a Google Hangout. Nick and his opponent play from the comfort of their own homes. This affects the sorts of games that can be played; the physical games are dialed down somewhat – though not entirely – and the puzzle content has been dialed up. (That said, Nick and his opponent have met face-to-face for two pre-recorded games already, leading to this trailer.) The game devisor is David J. Bodycombe, who has been producing puzzles for TV and print for over 20 years, possibly most notably for the first eight series of Only Connect (and the ninth series starts on BBC Four on Monday) and also for The Crystal Maze. Nick’s opponent is Daniel Peake, who co-runs Puzzled Pint in London.

The first episode took place in January and featured plenty of puzzly games: the first game was a word puzzle with a physical combination lock, the fifth game was a cracking and unusual strategy contest between the two, the sixth game saw the contestants complete jigsaws while blindfolded (much harder than you’d think, despite the jigsaws going out of their way to help), the thirteenth game was Mastermind and the eleventh was a Solo Chess series of puzzles that used chess-based concepts in an unusual and interesting fashion.

The first episode was played in excellent humour and was full of surprises; none of the games dragged and you knew there was something different coming up shortly. The second show should be at least as remarkable, with more interactive elements promised. The URL will be publicised within this post at Bother’s Bar at around 8pm UK time; follow also on Twitter using hashtag #sdb – and post your allegiance with either #teamdan or #imbackingbrig to play along!