Introducing the Exit Games UK inflation rate

Inflation rate graphIt is unclear whether increased competition is dragging the price of playing exit games down, or whether exit game suppliers are facing higher charges and being required to pass them on to consumers in turn. Somebody should track this, and this site doesn’t see anybody else doing so.

The principle behind the tracker aims to emulate the calculation processes behind the actual inflation calculation process. This site will establish a basket of exit game prices, then measure this basket periodically to establish whether there has been a trend in price changes. It may well be that there is no change for a period of several months, so do not expect especially frequent updates. As a policy decision, this basket will consider only UK prices, though will attempt to represent prices from all over the UK; a separate Irish basket may follow in time. (More specific baskets could also be possible – perhaps a Scottish basket or a London basket. These will not be considered in the first instance.)

Now individual exit games do come and will eventually go – hopefully, very, very eventually. Accordingly, it may not be the most appropriate measure to strictly define the basket in terms of specific games that are set in stone forever; a more specific example of a basket item might be “a 4-player game at an established popular site in London, during the afternoon at a weekend, booked 2-3 weeks in advance, not taking advantage of offers”. The identity of the site this refers to will be consistent as far as possible but is not necessarily set in stone forever – indeed, some basket items will deliberately change relatively frequently. For instance, some players delight in trying the latest new site, and this aspect of the experience should be considered, but new sites do not remain new forever! You will forgive this site for not identifying the specific games used.

There are many ways in which exit games and the prices they charge can be categorised: the game might be popular or less popular, the game might be in specific cities (or a generic provincial city, or a generic provincial town), the game might be established or new, the price might refer to a weekday or a weekend, the price might differ if it applies to evening play or afternoon play, the price might differ if it is booked in advance, the price might differ if an offer is used, and the most notable way in which a price will vary depends on the number of players in the team.

Accordingly, the basket considers a variety of team sizes, and uses data from photos of teams posted online (making the reasonable-seeming assumption that they are adequately representative…) to reasonably properly weight different team sizes according to how frequent they seem to be in real life, bearing in mind that some sites cater for larger teams than others – and, indeed, some sites have rooms that deliberately cater for teams of different sizes. Similarly, the basket attempts to reflect the perceived relative popularity of the various options in each categorisation.

This can only be an introduction to the principle, as this site has captured its first average price of basket items. There is no inflation rate to announce as there is no previous data to compare against. However, the next time this site captures the average price, an extremely preliminary inflation rate estimate would be possible.

Bigger games for bigger companies

adventure.ie's "jail break" activityOne way in which some exit games promote themselves is as an unusual team-building activity for corporate entertainment. If Plato is to be believed, “you can discover more about a person in an hour of play than in a year of conversation”; at the very least, there is over two millennia of wisdom in that maxim. However, even the largest exit game centre in the UK at the moment, London’s Escape Hunt, can only deal with ten groups playing at the same time. (They do have a large corporate breakout area, so they can cope with parties of 100; 50 playing the exit games, rotating with 50 involved with other team-building activities.)

Corporate entertainment companies have taken exit games’ popularity on board. While there is a decades-old tradition of corporate team-building, problem-solving and creativity-stretching events, it’s extremely interesting to see the approach that can be taken when you come from a set of corporate assumptions first and foremost, and possibly corporate assumptions about budget, rather than as a public-facing activity where players can be assumed to be paying their own way.

Eventus host Escape! for 6 to 200 people. The scenario takes place onboard an orbiting space-station. Each participant is a space officer candidate about to embark on the final stage of their officer training. […] As decisions are made the team will gradually learn more about their surroundings. In every “room” they enter they find something good (or maybe not so good!), plus a whole more doors leading deeper into the maze. The challenge is to find a way to the space portal (exit), negotiating all hazards en-route. Teams need to ensure their “life-clock” does not run out. There are radiation hazards, predators, and tough decisions to reach as the team builds up a picture of the space-station. And what about The Oracle? Surely every team will choose to pay The Oracle a visit to unearth some sage advice. Or maybe not? This is a table-based activity rather than having a physical maze to explore, but the company also have problem-solving activities that are rather more kinetic in Eliminator for 7-24 and Labyrinth for 15-200. That would be an unusually precious and gem-like labyrinth, if you get the reference.

Escaping from prison is a frequent exit game theme; the photo atop this article comes from adventure.ie, whose Jail Break event can be run in genuine gaols at either Wicklow or Cork. Parties of 20+ split into smaller teams. After an initial briefing each team is allocated their challenge book. This contains information on the 3 parts of their mission. The first part of the Jail Break event is a series of photos which the teams must find the location of and then answer the relevant questions. Part two of the Jail Break sees the teams solve a number of clues which will lead them to various parts of the jail to find the solution to the riddle. For the final part the teams must complete a number of fun challenges in the jail, these are all fun and non-strenuous. Bonus keys are also scattered around the gaol. The same company also offer treasure hunts and smartphone GPS-guided hunts in locations around Ireland.

Finally, with a tip of the hat to Sam from the forthcoming Enigma Escape, more about which before too long, there are a couple of hours left to book (and no time limit to enjoy thinking about) this already completely funded Kickstarter project, an escape game set in a prison in Rotterdam in the Netherlands. The prison is out of use and will be redeveloped in March, so there are a couple of months in which to use it for exciting projects. Up to 120 players will interact with the 20+ actors who inhabit the prison. We have cast of the best improvisational actors in the Netherlands playing different roles, from warden, priest, gang leaders, and many (corrupt?) guards. Maybe your interactions with them will give you the clues you need to find your way out! Some tickets are left for Real Life Gaming‘s public Dutch-language games in the middle of January, but a company that could pay €6,800 (just over £5,000 at current rates) and to pay to get 120 players to Rotterdam could get a private English-language game of their own.

Exciting possibilities! Even if you don’t work for a company progressive enough to take advantage of them, it’s fun and inspiring to wonder what more there might be over time.

Around the World: what’s going on in North America

Room Escape Artist's map of North American exit gamesThe above map is a snapshot of Room Escape Artist’s North American exit game map. (Hi! Thank you!)

Speaking of exit game maps, Live Escape Games‘ Shaun points Exit Games UK to the Puzzalarium newsletter, from the site of the same name of San Diego. This site has quickly made a name for itself from some of its unique approaches, as detailed in Toronto Room Escapes‘ brilliant, must-read interview. Puzzalarium have announced an approach which is brilliant, simple, lucrative, zero-cost and worthy of recognition as instant global best practice.

Simply, they offer the chance to play their room in “Zen mode”. You book, and pay for, one room for two adjacent time slots. You then get to play the room in no rush whatsoever over the duration of both timeslots… and the time in between them, normally filled in by the room being reset. (So if a game takes an hour, and there’s an hour reset time between games, this would give you up to three hours in total in the room.) This means that people can take the room as slowly as they like, possibly even taking no hints in a room where hints might usually be liberally supplied, and come out feeling that they can be pretty sure that they haven’t missed a single thing. At a guess, only a few percent of groups would feel that this is the right approach for them, and probably only for rooms known to be relatively difficult – but those who do, and who are willing to pay double money, would really appreciate the option. Puzzalarium also offer teams who have played their game the chance to watch other teams playing the game from behind the scenes.

Escape Room Directory‘s Dan Egnor points to Dr. Bryan Clair‘s amazing, detailed account of an intricate-looking exit game he set up and ran for 36 teams at St. Louis University. (He’s also volunteering to run DASH 7 in St. Louis, where it’ll be making a return after being present for DASHes 4 and 5, and absent for number 6. What a guy!) Amateur exit rooms like this are definitely part of the future of the genre and might be right for some people who love the idea of devising and running their own exit game but don’t feel well-suited to the business aspect of things. (Plus who have the resources to sink into such a project, without getting an obvious financial return from it.) Dr. Clair, this site salutes you!

Talking of interviews and taking looks behind the scenes, the latest (and last, at least for the year… and maybe longer?) episode of the consistently beloved and heroic Snoutcast podcast features an interview with Lindsay Morse and Nate Martin of Puzzle Break of Seattle and San Francisco. Nate also previously wrote this Reddit post with his reflections on his first year in business.

Lastly, this site just loves the theme behind Omescape of Markham, Ontario’s new room: the Kingdom of Cats. It opened yesterday; obviously, on a Caturday!

Last minute shopping ideas

Blank generic holiday gift certificateHow does the old saying go? Isn’t it “if you love somebody, lock ’em in a room”?

Some of u… er, you may still be looking for an unusual gift for a loved one, whatever you’re celebrating. The usual gift here would be a very unusual gift for most recipients. Many sites sell gift vouchers year-round, others tailor them to the season. Here are links to the gift vouchers that this site could quickly find; if your site has a voucher that isn’t in this list, please do say so and the error will be rectified with apologies.

The links below usually take you to pages on the site that specifically detail gift vouchers, but some just take you to pages that invite you to contact them about gift vouchers if there is nothing more specific. This site does not attract any commission from using any of these links.

Proceeding roughly from south to north:

If you are unlucky enough to receive a more generic experience day gift voucher, this site is not aware of any opportunity to use it to play an exit game, but such experience day vouchers would be much more attractive if only such a deal could be struck…

The League Table: end of November 2014

Graph showing a brief kink in an upward trendA slightly different graph to the usual one this month. Exit games have never been more popular, but a certain drunken owl decision has had a considerable impact on one particular column of figures. The upward trend will surely return very shortly.

This is the eighth instalment of an occasional feature to act as a status report on the exit games in the UK and Ireland. On its own it means little, but repeated sufficiently many times it could be the basis of a survey of growth over time.

The Census

Category Number in the UK Number in Ireland
Exit game sites known to have opened 28 2
Exit game sites known to be open 25 2
Exit game sites known to have closed temporarily
(but “temporary” has been over seven months now)
1 0
Exit game sites apparently not taking bookings and listed as “for sale” in the UK/Ireland 1 0
Exit game sites known to have closed permanently 1 0
Exit game sites showing convincing evidence of being under construction 6 0
Exit game sites showing unconvincing evidence of being under construction 4 0
Exit game projects abandoned before opening 2 0

The term opened should be understood to include “sold tickets”, even if it is unclear whether any of those tickets may have been redeemed for played games; the definition of site should be understood to include outdoor sites and component parts of larger attractions that are played in the same way as conventional exit games.

A sad second entry to the new “abandoned before opening” category is that of Brighton Escape Room of Brighton; this had a web site that was close to completion, almost-there social media and an opening month even if not an opening date. Unfortunately, there was never any evidence of getting further than that; now, even the web site has gone. This site even visited the claimed location and saw no signs of life, so sadly this one has to be put back in its box for now, with fond thoughts. Brighton is such a promising market that someone must surely make a success of it before at all long.

The Report Card

Site name Number of exit rooms Number of different games Number of TripAdvisor reviews Number of 5/5 TripAdvisor reviews TripAdvisor’s “thumbs up” percentage Local TripAdvisor ranking
Agent November 2 2 16 15 100% 145
Bath Escape 2 2 34 33 100% 5
Breakout Manchester 4 4 167 149 97% 3
Cipher 1 1 – – – –
Clue HQ 2 2 197 187 99% 1
clueQuest 5 2 834 782 99% 15
Cryptopia 1 1 26 23 100% 11
Cyantist 1 1 2 2 – 23
Escape Edinburgh 3 2 227 207 99% 8
Escape Glasgow 2 1 51 49 100% 2
Escape Hunt 10 3 48 41 93% 126
Escape Land 1 1 70 59 100% 82
Escape Newcastle 2 1 5 4 – 13
Escape Quest 1 1 4 4 – 1
Escape Rooms 2 2 78 62 97% 111
ESCAP3D Belfast 1 1 107 83 89% 29
ESCAP3D Dublin 2 1 11 5 77% 159
Ex(c)iting Game 2 2 46 32 93% 12
GR8escape York 1 1 10 10 100% 18
HintHunt 5 2 1087 1007 98% 21
Jailbreak! 1 1 – – – –
Keyhunter 3 3 52 30 88% 18
Locked In Games 2 2 23 21 100% 5
Logiclock 1 1 – – – –
Make A Break 1 1 49 31 86% 23
Puzzlair 2 2 91 87 98% 1
The Gr8 Escape 2 2 26 23 100% 19
Tick Tock Unlock 1 1 196 186 99% 1
XIT 4 4 8 5 100% 115

This needs to be taken with a heavy pinch of salt. This site supports all the exit games that exist and will not make claims that any particular one is superior to any other particular one. Please note that the TripAdvisor rankings represent a wide variety of locations and cannot be directly compared against each other. In fact, it’s probably pushing it even to compare the TripAdvisor rankings of two exit game sites in the same city. If you are comparing one site’s rankings from month to month, it might be best to consider this month as representing a discontinuity in the series as TripAdvisor have reclassified exit games from being attractions to being activities.

This perhaps represents exit games being a victim of their own success and spreading so far and wide. When there were only a few, perhaps it was reasonable to think of them as something worth travelling from afar for. However, now they have become so widespread, perhaps they are more naturally considered competitors of other leisure activities that you might find in your locality. It’s hugely impressive that despite the bigger competition, there are still four sites ranked the number one activity in their town, and the move has even helped a couple of sites out. However, many more sites have struggled, particularly in the English and Scottish capitals.

This site is also going to start tracking the “thumbs up” proportion, as quoted by TripAdvisor. In theory, this reflects the proportion of either 5/5 or 4/5 votes, though there might be some slight anomalies. A 4/5 vote is no bad thing. This site wouldn’t emphasise the difference between a 98% thumbs-up site and a 99% thumbs-up site, though perhaps there might be a significant difference between a 100% thumbs-up site and an 80% thumbs-up site. All these extremely high proportions are massively impressive and to the credit of all the exit game sites out there.

In the light of new evidence, this site revises up its previous estimate that the number of people who have played at least one exit game in the UK or Ireland by the end of October is 90,000, and that the number of people who have played at least one exit game by the end of November is 105,000. (It seems reasonable to round to the nearest 5,000 rather than the nearest 1,000 now.) As ever, if someone plays more than one game at the same site, this figure still only counts them once, and this number is only really meaningful in context of this site’s previous estimates.

This site is often unimpressed by grandiose claims of the unlikely popularity of an activity, which is the reason for trying to keep a running total. On the other hand, making deliberately low estimates would not serve the industry well either – imagine basing a decision to invest in a business on the basis that it is claimed that only 150,000 people have played when the true figure is close to a million! While this site never claims great confidence in the figures, because there are assumptions made that might go either way, it knows that there is at least consistent and arguably justifiable method to the madness.

Fatal Attraction

This owl has been drinkingIt would appear that a certain well-known owl has made some very unwise decisions, wound up cross-eyed and fallen over. Perhaps he has decided to celebrate (American) Thanksgiving by introducing himself to WHISKEY. Foolish owl.

What has inspired this parody? Well, a certain review aggregation site which shall remain nameless has decided to recategorise the exit games that this site covers from being attractions to being activities. This is clearly a political decision, if not a party political one, and it seems that the activities category faces rather… tougher competition than the attractions one. Some outstanding sites with a hard-earned reputation arising from many, many excellent reviews have found themselves relegated from #1 in their field to, er, rather lower. This does not reflect the sites getting worse in any way, shape or form, but does spell bad news for the visibility of the industry as a whole.

What can be done about this? Well, theoretically this support answer suggests that it might be possible to claim that “A listing has wrong information or is categorized incorrectly” and get sites’ categories changed back from activity to attraction. On the other hand, while most people will not have access to one particular private forum, one of the top questions is Why has my listing been moved to the Activities Tab? – to which the answer begins A recent update to the site has moved some businesses over to the Activities tab. It is not a mistake and an intentional re-categorization (…) It may well not be specific towards exit games in any way, shape or form.

Nuts.

(Tip of the hat to Nathan from Agent November for pointing this out.)

Here’s to the workers

Workforce graphicSuggestions for a better graphic, in the public domain, that more accurately and positively reflects the diversity of the workforce would be welcome; there are far more traditionally male sets of clothing and body shapes above than would be at all representative.

There is a model of an exit game as being operated by a sole proprietor, or better still a couple, where the extremely small team miraculously has a very wide collection of skills, does everything themselves and only has to pay themselves. Many exit games start off that way. However, when games become more successful, expanding the business by taking on more staff becomes essential.

It would be a fair criticism of this site that it may play into the stereotype of sole proprietor as superhero; all the interviews so far have been with proprietors or CEOs, when in truth they’re only one part of the team, and may well be far from being on the front line for a great proportion of their day. Many exit games which have great reviews earn specific praise for the friendliness of their staff and the quality of their service. At least in bigger sites, that may not be down to the proprietors, that may be down to the staff. This site hopes that the staff can take as much pride in their site’s success as the management do.

This site gets the impression that many, even relatively successful, sites are not yet earning very substantial revenues, so fears that the exit game industry is not yet one that can necessarily pay its staff particularly well. This may well be reasonably common for a customer service job. Hopefully the degree of fun that both staff and customers have may make this relatively pleasant as customer service jobs go, and hopefully the best staff can be recognised and rewarded, and good practice can be shared within sites and more widely around the industry.

Several site proprietors read this site from time to time; it’s not clear whether site employees do, too. If you are an employee and you do read this, THANK YOU! It’s the people on the front line who are responsible for so much of the success of the industry. Perspectives of what it’s like to work at a site would be extremely welcome and pseudonyms will be respected.

Exit games in the news

Newspaper graphicSome longer posts, some shorter ones. Here’s a quick round-up of recent mass media stories about exit games.

  • Can You Escape of Edinburgh have a preview in the Edinburgh Reporter, which reveals three interesting things that this site did not previously know: a leaderboard of fastest escape times is at least implied, the venue has plans to double in capacity from one room to two early in 2015 and the business has received funding and support from Business Gateway Edinburgh. Might other potential (and even existing?) operators around the UK and Ireland be able to get assistance from their local business incubators? It’s something well worth considering.
     
  • Logiclock of Nottingham have a story in the Nottingham Post about their background and opening. The site also has fifty half-price tickets available as an opening discount for teams who are willing to dig through the web site and find the unusually-coloured digits. If you’re good enough to play and win their pirate-themed game, finding this code should be a snap.
     
  • It didn’t raise mass media interest, but it did raise a smile; Puzzlair of Bristol recently had their youngest player ever, a 10-week-old baby. By implication, this baby did manage to break out in time… inside their nappy.
     
  • Not a UK story, but really interesting: Escape Games of Toronto were profiled in Canada’s largest newspaper’s “Business Club”. The site has five rooms, with three more coming soon, and a large lobby where you can borrow board games to play on-site before or after your escape mission. (A good match, though it must help that Canada is so large that rents might not be nearly so much of an issue as they are in the UK.) The site is recommended by Toronto Room Escapes, a rare honour, though the Escape Games Review, er, review is also well worth reading.

    It’s particularly interesting in that it discusses what a really high-end site has to do to survive in an extremely crowded market, far more crowded locally than any in the UK, even that of London. This site is much more bullish about exit games’ future than the proprietor is, though perhaps Toronto and Budapest over time might go to show what market saturation might look like. The article is extremely interesting for its view behind the scenes and also for the free consultancy provided by a number of the best local business brains, which might yet prove food for thought, subject to local adaptation, for site owners closer to home.

Thinking big: what would a million players a year look like?

A heart marked "1,000,000"One of this site’s writers was talking to one of his co-workers the other day and the co-worker said “So do you know about this (name deleted) escape game in (city), then? My wife played it the other day and she loved it.” Yes. Yes, it’s possible that one or two things about it might be known. This site considers it great news, as more and more evidence, albeit anecdotal, that the word is getting out to the masses. Fingers crossed, some more enthusiasm may well get them to play the others that exist as well.

One of the bigger questions that this site wonders about from time to time is just how big exit games can get. (For the sake of expediency and laziness, let’s stick to the UK here.) A million players a year is a big, splashy number to talk about; by comparison, UK Paintball claims “over a million paintball players per year in the UK”, with one brand alone claiming half a million players in a year. (Another reputable source estimated about 1,100,000 players +/- 150,000 players.) These figures count one person playing once a month as twelve players, which seems like a reasonable basis. (This site’s monthly player count estimate differs by factoring to count unique players.)

There are some hobbies which lock their players in by incentivising, or even requiring, players to spend very considerable sums of money on specific equipment for that hobby alone. This site contends that it’s to the exit game industry’s credit that that isn’t a factor; the low barrier of entry makes attracting new players easier. Granted, the games themselves are often not cheap, but the habitually high reviews provide evidence that almost all players consider that you do get what you pay for. (There are other parts of the puzzle hobby, particularly online, which do not have a price tag.) On the other hand, the lack of commitment and the lack of replay value for an individual room means there’s a challenge for the industry to go from “this is something fun I did once” to “this is one of my regular hobbies”. Sites with more than one different game are a step in the right direction.

In round terms, one million players a year is 20,000 players a week, which might mean 12,000 players during the week and four or five thousand players on a Saturday. To keep the numbers simple, let’s say that a busy Saturday might see as many as 1,200 teams play, and let’s assume that each room can service an average of six teams per day on a Saturday. Then, all as an order of magnitude calculation, a million players a year might feel like 200 rooms all fully booked out every Saturday. (And most of Sunday, and fairly heavily on weekdays as well.)

The last time The League Table was computed, it estimated 55 open rooms (not sites!) in the UK, plus more in the Republic of Ireland. The total has gone up since then. Nevertheless, we would looking at roughly a trebling in size of the industry, plus an increase in utilisation of the less popular sites to approach that of the most popular sites. Escape Hunt in London has ten rooms, ClueQuest and HintHunt each have five these days, Breakout Manchester have four and some others have three. Some sites have plenty of room for expansion; many others may not have much space to get past 4-5 rooms within a single site, others limiting themselves to as few as two rooms, or one. If the current average is 2.5 rooms per site, and if that average might rise towards 3 rooms per site, we might expect 70 sites to be required (and Escape Hunt not to be the only mega-site).

You might choose to create an immediately familiar, but very crude, model of this as one centre located at a town for each Premier League or Championship football team, 16 more dotted around locations with lower league teams, plus 10 more dotted around Scotland – again, perhaps in line with football powerhouses – as well Northern Ireland and the rest of Wales. This provides some basis for modelling big conurbations featuring both more and (in some cases) better-used locations than smaller conurbations. A slightly less crude model might emphasise tourism destinations more highly, with business destinations and dormitory towns emphasised less highly. (Question for site owners: which football team do you identify your site with? Silly analogies are fun!)

Is a million players a year realistic? The population of the UK is something like 64 million, so (again, keeping the numbers very simple) this might roughly be looking at 1% of the population playing at least one game a year, a substantial proportion of those being “hobbyists” who play more than one game, and tourists from outside the UK playing in UK sites as well.

Getting as high as 1% is far from easy, though. While there will always be some very young players, some very senior players and some players with disabilities, all of whom will be at least as welcome as others, it’s not unrealistic to knock – say – 30% of the population out straight away as considering themselves to be too young, too old or too impaired to be interested in playing. We can then factor out those who identify as being without disposable income, when everybody is struggling, and those who identify as having no interest in intellectual activities. Maybe that’s another 30% right there. (That’s a pretty wild guess, but compare to video game player stats.) So you’re looking at a target market of perhaps 40% of the population, thus the industry is looking to get 1-in-40 of those to play in a year. Does that seem reasonable? Alternatively, considering how popular these games are with the early adopters who have tried them, does that seem low?

Another point of reference is that in 2013, there were something like 170 million paid admissions to UK cinemas. (The trend over time dipped to about 70 million in the early ’80s at its lowest and has been broadly recovering, with fluctuations, ever since.) Might half a percent or one percent of that seem a reasonable aspiration?

This site is bullish about these estimates. If you are, too, then it’s clear that the market has plenty of room to grow and it’s not close to being too late to get involved. Perhaps a million UK players in 2017 is not out of sight; a real optimist might see a seven-digit year being reached sooner still.

New section: Getting into the exit games business

"Come in we're Open" graphicThis site is happy to open a major new section, detailing its theories and conclusions about running an exit game.

This is, of course, extremely presumptuous as the people behind it have never actually run one. Nevertheless, having paid attention to sites’ operations, there are enough commonalities and good practice available to be observed that it would appear to be useful to try to draw them all together into a single document. The advice within can never be more than just suggestions, and there are many famous quotes about just how little advice can be worth. Hopefully it can be taken in the sense of “food for thought”, and give both potential market entrants and existing players some suggestions. The majority of points within should be globally applicable, though there are a few that are more specific to the UK and Ireland.

Corrections, suggestions for improvement and other comments from site operators are especially welcome and will be gratefully received; please send them through by e-mail. If any of the advice looks positively harmful, please shout up at once. It’s a living document which will be updated from time to time; many thanks to those site operators who have provided their opinions on an earlier version of it already.